Jump to content

User:Cagliost

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Aviation articles

[edit]

Articles I have done substantial work on

[edit]

Articles I created

[edit]

Minor contributions

[edit]

Articles that need more work

[edit]

Verifiability and truth

[edit]

Wikipedia has a policy of Wikipedia:Verifiability. Claims should be sourced so readers can verify them independently. Essay Wikipedia:Verifiability, not truth explains this further. I disagree; I think claims should be verifiable and true. Editors should not include information they know or strongly believe to be false, even if they can find normally-reliable sources stating it to be true. Sources with a history of reliability can make mistakes.

Wikipedia has a policy to avoid primary sources in biographical articles (WP:BLPPRIMARY). However, in the case of Rachel Weisz's birthday, there were conflicting secondary sources for her birthdate. It was clear from primary sources what her birthday really was, and so primary sources were used to dismiss the incorrect secondary sources and support the correct secondary sources.

In the case of James Mullinger, there was an incorrect source giving his high-school, and no source giving the correct school. Primary sources were used to delete the false claim, though the correct information could not be added because no correct secondary sources existed.

In the case of Ronnie Hazlehurst, someone edited Wikipedia to state he wrote the lyrics to Reach by S Club 7. This claim was reported by the BBC, The Times and The Guardian. Some editors then tried to use these references in the article, despite saying they knew them to be false.